Something unusual is happening inside the Shopify agency ecosystem, and it’s making Klaviyo’s partner team uncomfortable. Over the past 90 days, at least a half-dozen mid-to-large Shopify-focused agencies — the kind that manage $10M–$80M in annual client revenue — have quietly begun shifting new client onboardings away from Klaviyo and toward Attentive, according to sources close to the matter. The trigger, multiple insiders say, is a restructured Attentive partner program that is reportedly offering agencies 20–25% recurring revenue share on annual contracts, compared to what partners describe as Klaviyo’s “effectively flat” referral economics since its 2023 IPO.
“Klaviyo went public and the partner program got worse, not better,” said one agency founder who asked not to be named but whose firm manages email and SMS programs for over 40 Shopify Plus brands. “Attentive came in this spring with a deck that made our CFO’s eyes light up. We’re talking real recurring revenue, not a one-time referral credit.”
Klaviyo and Attentive both declined to confirm specific revenue-share figures. A Klaviyo spokesperson said the company “continuously invests in its agency partner program” and pointed to its certified partner directory, which now lists over 5,000 global agencies. Attentive did not respond to a request for comment before publication.
What Is Attentive Allegedly Offering That Klaviyo Isn’t?
According to three agency operators who say they attended private Attentive partner briefings in Q2 2026, the pitch goes beyond revenue share. Attentive is reportedly offering dedicated agency success managers, co-marketing budget for joint case studies, and — critically — priority access to its SMS AI Send-Time Optimization feature, which the company has branded Attentive AI, for agency-managed accounts at no additional cost to the end client.
- Recurring rev-share reportedly in the 20–25% range on annual SMS contracts
- Dedicated partner success managers (not shared reps)
- Co-branded case study funding of reportedly $5,000–$15,000 per approved study
- Early access to Attentive AI send-time features for agency-managed accounts
- Joint webinar and conference sponsorship opportunities
“The co-marketing piece is what closes it for a lot of agencies,” said one operator who runs a 30-person DTC growth agency in Austin. “Klaviyo used to do that stuff. Now getting co-marketing dollars out of them feels like pulling teeth.”
Is Andrew Bialecki’s Team Aware of the Defections?
Sources suggest Klaviyo CEO Andrew Bialecki and chief revenue officer Amanda Whalen are aware of the agency friction but have internally characterized it as a “partner mix optimization” rather than a defection problem. The company’s stated strategy since its IPO has been to reduce dependency on agency-driven leads and grow direct enterprise sales — a move that, unconfirmed sources say, has quietly deprioritized the mid-market agency tier that made Klaviyo’s early growth possible.
“Klaviyo built its empire on agencies. If they’re walking away from that relationship, Attentive will absolutely fill that vacuum — and they’ll do it fast.” — agency principal, identity withheld
One former Klaviyo partner manager, who left the company in early 2026 and is now consulting independently, told Ecommerce Times that internal quota pressure on direct sales reps has allegedly created friction where reps and agency partners are competing for the same accounts. “I watched it happen in real time,” this person said. “An agency would bring in a lead, and a direct rep would swoop in and try to close it themselves for full commission credit. That kills partner trust fast.”
Klaviyo disputes this characterization. A spokesperson said the company has “clear rules of engagement” to prevent channel conflict and that agency-sourced deals are “appropriately attributed and compensated.”
Which Agencies Are Reportedly Making the Switch?
Ecommerce Times was unable to independently verify specific agency names, as most principals declined to speak on record for fear of damaging existing Klaviyo client relationships. However, sources point to movement in the New York and Los Angeles agency clusters that serve fashion and beauty DTC brands — sectors where SMS engagement rates are reportedly highest and where Attentive has historically had strong case study data.
One name that surfaced in multiple conversations was Sharma Brands, the growth shop led by Nik Sharma, though a spokesperson for Sharma Brands said the firm “works with multiple platforms depending on client fit” and declined to comment on any shift in platform preference. Nik Sharma himself posted obliquely on LinkedIn in June 2026 that “the best partner programs reward agencies that actually drive growth, not just certifications” — a post that generated significant speculation in agency Slack communities, sources say.
“The best partner programs reward agencies that actually drive growth, not just certifications.” — Nik Sharma, LinkedIn, June 2026
How Is This Affecting DTC Brand Decision-Making at the Point of Sale?
The downstream effect on brands may be more significant than either platform is publicly acknowledging. When an agency switches preferred-platform allegiance, brands often follow — particularly founder-led DTC companies that rely heavily on agency guidance for tech stack decisions. Sources estimate that a single mid-size agency with 40 active Shopify Plus clients could represent $800K–$2M in annual platform contract value if those clients are onboarded to a new SMS or email provider.
“We had three clients ask us to evaluate Attentive in the last 60 days,” said one agency growth lead who confirmed the firm is a current Klaviyo Gold Partner. “Two of those came directly after we showed them case studies we were building with Attentive. The clients didn’t even know we were exploring the switch — they just responded to better data.”
- Average Shopify Plus brand SMS contract: $1,500–$6,000/month depending on list size
- Agencies managing 30–50 clients could shift $500K+ in ARR with a platform preference change
- Onboarding friction remains a real deterrent — migrating SMS subscriber lists is operationally messy
- Brands with combined Klaviyo email + SMS contracts face higher switching costs than SMS-only accounts
Could This Drama Accelerate a Klaviyo Product Response?
Industry observers note that Klaviyo is not sitting still. The company rolled out a refreshed agency tier structure in May 2026 that added a new “Elite” designation above its existing Gold and Platinum tiers, reportedly unlocking additional support resources and a dedicated account pod. But sources who have seen the Elite program terms say the revenue-share component remains “modest” compared to what Attentive is allegedly dangling.
“Klaviyo’s response was to add a badge,” said one agency founder with visible frustration. “Attentive’s response was to add a check.”
There is also the product dimension. Klaviyo’s combined email-SMS platform remains a genuine competitive advantage for agencies running integrated lifecycle programs — Attentive’s email product, launched in 2023, is still viewed by many operators as a work in progress compared to Klaviyo’s mature segmentation and flow builder. Several agency contacts noted they would not move email workloads to Attentive, creating a bifurcated stack situation that adds operational complexity for their teams.
“We’re not leaving Klaviyo for email. We’re supplementing it with Attentive for SMS — and Klaviyo should be very worried about what that means for renewal conversations in 18 months.” — DTC agency operator, identity withheld
What Happens Next — and Should Brands Be Paying Attention?
The situation remains fluid and unconfirmed at scale. Neither Klaviyo nor Attentive has made any public statement about partner program changes, and it’s possible the agency defections are more anecdotal than structural at this stage. But the underlying economics of ecommerce agency revenue sharing have been under pressure industrywide, and any platform that can meaningfully improve an agency’s P&L through recurring rev-share has a structural advantage in partner recruiting.
For DTC founders and Shopify operators, the practical implication is worth watching: if your agency is getting financial incentives to recommend one platform over another, that’s a conversation worth having openly. The best operators in 2026 are auditing their agency relationships the same way they audit their ad spend — with an eye toward misaligned incentives.
As of press time, Attentive had not confirmed or denied the partner program terms described in this report. Klaviyo declined to provide specific revenue-share figures but maintained its partner program “remains one of the strongest in the industry.” Ecommerce Times will continue to monitor this story as Q3 partner renewal cycles begin in August.