The SMS marketing wars just got a little more personal. Sources close to the matter say that Attentive — the Newark-based SMS platform that has long positioned itself as the premium choice for high-volume DTC brands — quietly lost its Vice President of Creative Strategy, Dana Merrick, sometime in late July 2026. Merrick, who was reportedly instrumental in building Attentive’s AI Journeys product and shepherding marquee clients including Anthropologie, Pura Vida, and several undisclosed eight-figure Shopify operators, has allegedly landed at Postscript, Attentive’s most aggressive direct rival in the Shopify ecosystem.
Neither Attentive nor Postscript has confirmed the hire publicly as of press time. Attentive’s communications team did not respond to a request for comment. A Postscript spokesperson said only that the company “does not comment on personnel matters.” But multiple agency sources — including leaders at two of the top five Attentive-certified partner agencies — say the departure is real, and the internal fallout has been significant.
“Dana was the person who made Attentive’s creative playbooks feel like something you’d actually use in the real world. Losing her to Postscript right before Q4 is not a small thing. That’s institutional knowledge walking out the door.” — Senior strategist at a Klaviyo and Attentive partner agency, speaking anonymously
What Does Merrick’s Alleged Move Mean for Attentive’s Agency Relationships?
The timing is particularly awkward for Attentive. The company spent much of H1 2026 aggressively marketing its AI Journeys product — a behavioral-trigger SMS flow engine that competes directly with Postscript’s Automations suite and Klaviyo’s expanded SMS layer. Agency partners who build SMS programs for DTC brands say Merrick was a key contact for advanced creative strategy, often bridging the gap between Attentive’s product team and the agency operators trying to squeeze conversion lift out of complex abandoned cart and post-purchase sequences.
Sources say at least two mid-market agencies that manage over $40 million in combined client SMS spend are now “actively evaluating” their Attentive commitments ahead of contract renewals in Q1 2027. One agency founder, who asked not to be named, said the departure “accelerated conversations” that had already been happening internally about platform diversification.
- Attentive reportedly holds contracts with over 8,000 brands globally, per its own 2025 marketing materials
- Postscript has been aggressively courting Attentive’s mid-market accounts since its Series C in early 2025
- Klaviyo’s combined email-SMS bundle has been winning accounts that previously ran split-stack strategies
- Sources say Yotpo’s SMS product has also been pitching recently-departed Attentive agency contacts
Is Postscript Making a Deliberate Play for Attentive’s Talent and Clients?
Inside the SMS ecosystem, Merrick’s alleged hire is being read as anything but coincidental. Postscript CEO Adam Turner has been unusually vocal in 2026 about targeting Attentive’s client base, telling attendees at a private Shopify partner dinner in Austin in May that Postscript was “done playing nice” and intended to win “at the high end of the market” before Q4. Sources who attended that dinner say the comment drew uncomfortable laughter from at least one Attentive partner agency rep in the room.
“Adam has never been shy about who he’s going after. Hiring someone like Dana, if that’s what actually happened, is a statement. That’s not an accident.” — A DTC growth consultant who works with both platforms
Unconfirmed reports also suggest that Postscript has been offering aggressive migration incentives to brands currently on Attentive — including waived onboarding fees and 90-day performance guarantees on deliverability benchmarks. One Shopify merchant running a seven-figure apparel brand told Ecommerce Times she received a cold outreach from a Postscript account executive in early August citing “personnel changes at a competitor” as a reason to consider switching. She declined to name the platform referenced but said the framing was “unusually pointed.”
How Is Attentive Responding Internally to the Departure?
Sources describe the atmosphere inside Attentive’s go-to-market organization as “tense but controlled.” The company reportedly held an all-hands creative strategy session in the first week of August to reassure agency partners that product development on AI Journeys would continue on schedule. Attentive’s Chief Revenue Officer, Brian Long — who also co-founded the company alongside Andrew Jones — was said to be personally on calls with several top-tier agency partners the week of August 11.
One source with direct knowledge of those calls said Long emphasized that Attentive’s Q4 roadmap, which reportedly includes deeper integration with Shopify’s new checkout extensibility layer and a revamped predictive send-time optimization engine, remains “fully intact.” But the source added that Long’s personal involvement in partner reassurance calls was itself telling — that level of executive attention for what would otherwise be a normal personnel transition suggests the company is treating this as a reputational moment, not just an HR matter.
“When your CRO is personally calling agency partners to tell them not to worry, you have to ask what exactly they’re worried about.” — Anonymous agency CEO managing over $15M in SMS client spend
What Does This Mean for the Broader SMS Platform Market Heading Into Q4?
The alleged Merrick departure is landing at a complicated moment for the SMS category overall. Klaviyo’s aggressive bundling strategy — offering SMS seat pricing tied to existing email contracts — has been quietly eroding the standalone SMS market that both Attentive and Postscript depend on. Several DTC founders who spoke to Ecommerce Times at the Shopify Unite partner event in Toronto last month said they had consolidated onto Klaviyo’s combined stack specifically to reduce vendor complexity, not because of any dissatisfaction with Attentive’s product.
Meanwhile, Yotpo continues to pitch its loyalty-plus-SMS bundle to brands already on its reviews and referral platform, and Omnisend has reportedly been gaining ground among Shopify merchants doing under $5 million in annual revenue who find Attentive’s pricing difficult to justify at lower send volumes.
- Klaviyo’s SMS revenue reportedly grew 34% YoY through Q2 2026, per analyst estimates
- Attentive claims over 30% average revenue lift for brands using AI Journeys, though independent verification is limited
- Postscript’s reported ARR crossed $80M in early 2026 according to sources familiar with its financials
- Industry observers say Q4 2026 will be the most competitive quarter ever for SMS platform market share
Should DTC Brands Be Worried About Platform Stability Right Now?
For operators, the practical question is whether this kind of executive turbulence — confirmed or not — should factor into platform decisions ahead of the highest-stakes selling period of the year. Most experienced SMS practitioners say the answer is almost certainly no at the tactical level: flows built in Attentive still run, deliverability infrastructure doesn’t change with a single personnel departure, and switching costs mid-Q3 would be operationally catastrophic for most brands.
But at the strategic level, several agency operators say the episode is a useful reminder to audit platform dependency and ensure that institutional SMS knowledge — message templates, segment logic, A/B test archives — lives in the agency or brand’s own documentation, not locked inside a vendor relationship. One growth agency MD put it bluntly:
“We’ve been preaching ‘own your SMS program, not just your list’ for two years. This is exactly the kind of moment that proves the point. Your flows should be portable even if your platform isn’t.”
For now, the SMS market is watching closely. If Postscript announces a senior creative strategy hire in the coming weeks — or if Attentive’s Q4 roadmap shows any visible slippage — the speculation will only intensify. In a category where product roadmaps and personal relationships are often indistinguishable, losing the right person at the wrong moment can echo well past a single contract cycle.