Something unusual has been circulating in the private Slack channels and invite-only seller forums that sit just below the public surface of the Amazon ecosystem. Over the past six weeks, multiple sources — including a brand manager at a nine-figure Amazon-native housewares brand, a senior account executive at a major Seattle-based agency, and a former Amazon Vendor Services rep — have independently described what they’re calling “Project Lighthouse,” an alleged internal Amazon initiative that would dynamically adjust FBA fulfillment fees based on a seller’s so-called velocity score: a composite metric reportedly incorporating sell-through rate, return rate, restock consistency, and customer satisfaction signals.
Amazon has not confirmed the existence of any such program. A spokesperson declined to comment when contacted by Ecommerce Times on July 9. But the volume and specificity of the chatter has rattled enough mid-to-large operators that it’s becoming one of the more discussed unconfirmed stories in the space right now.
What Is Amazon’s ‘Project Lighthouse’ — and How Would It Work?
According to three sources who claim to have been briefed — directly or indirectly — by Amazon account managers, Project Lighthouse would represent a significant structural departure from Amazon’s current flat-fee FBA model. Under the alleged framework, sellers with high velocity scores would qualify for tiered fee reductions of between 4% and 11% on per-unit fulfillment costs. Sellers with poor scores — high return rates, inconsistent inbound shipments, elevated customer contacts — would face surcharges layered on top of the existing FBA rate card.
“It’s essentially a loyalty discount system dressed up in logistics language,” said one agency leader who asked to remain anonymous. “If true, it rewards the sellers Amazon already wants and taxes the ones it’s quietly trying to push out.”
Sources close to the matter say the pilot is allegedly being tested with a cohort of roughly 200 to 400 sellers in the Home & Kitchen and Sports & Outdoors categories — two of the highest-return verticals on the platform.
Which Sellers Are Allegedly Already in the Loop?
Perhaps the most provocative detail circulating in seller communities is the claim that a small number of large brands have reportedly already received informal previews of the program through their dedicated Amazon Strategic Account Services (SAS) reps. Unconfirmed reports on the Seller Central subreddit and in the Prosper Show alumni Facebook group suggest that at least two well-known brands — one in the supplement-adjacent wellness hardware space, another in pet accessories — have been told to “prepare their operational benchmarks” for a fee structure change sometime in Q4 2026.
Scott Needham, founder of BuyBoxer and host of the Smart Seller podcast, addressed the rumors obliquely in an episode published July 7, noting that “there are credible whispers about a performance-linked fee model that would be bigger than the inbound placement changes.” He stopped short of confirming details.
“If Amazon actually executes a velocity-based fee tier, it changes the entire calculus on whether you optimize for volume or margin. You can’t do both the same way anymore.” — Scott Needham, BuyBoxer
Meanwhile, Kevin King, a well-known Amazon educator and Helium 10 Freedom Ticket instructor, reportedly told attendees at a private mastermind event in Austin last month that he had “heard enough from enough people” to believe something structural was coming to FBA pricing before the end of the year, though he framed it as unconfirmed speculation.
How Are Amazon Agencies and Tool Vendors Reacting?
The agency community is reportedly divided on whether Project Lighthouse represents an opportunity or an existential threat to their service model. Larger performance-focused agencies — think Incrementum Digital, Trivium Group, and Brands on Brands on Brands — would theoretically benefit if the program rewards optimized operations, since their managed accounts tend to run tighter sell-through and lower return rates than self-managed sellers.
But mid-market agencies that manage high-SKU catalogs with inconsistent inbound disciplines are allegedly more nervous. “We have clients who are great at PPC and terrible at forecasting,” one agency COO told us, requesting anonymity. “If Amazon starts penalizing restocking inconsistency, we’re going to have some very uncomfortable conversations.”
On the software side, sources say Jungle Scout and Helium 10 have both reportedly tasked internal product teams with modeling what a velocity score might look like based on existing data points already visible to sellers — sell-through rate, IPI score, ASIN-level return metrics — so they can build dashboards or alerts if and when the program goes live. Neither company commented on record.
- Helium 10: Allegedly exploring a “Lighthouse Readiness” dashboard feature for its Diamond and Elite tiers
- Jungle Scout: Reportedly modeling velocity score proxies into its Inventory Manager module
- Perpetua: Sources say the ad automation platform is internally discussing how dynamic fee changes would affect its bid optimization logic
- Feedvisor: Unconfirmed reports suggest it has already begun stress-testing repricing models against hypothetical fee tier scenarios
Is This Amazon’s Play to Further Squeeze Out Smaller FBA Sellers?
The cynical read — and it’s a popular one in seller forums — is that Project Lighthouse, if real, is less about rewarding great operators and more about accelerating the quiet consolidation Amazon has been engineering for several years. Since the 2024 inbound placement fee rollout and the 2025 low-inventory-level surcharge expansion, the cost burden on small and mid-size FBA sellers has risen materially. A performance-based fee layer would, critics argue, add another structural disadvantage for sub-$500K-per-year sellers who lack the operational infrastructure to maintain consistently high velocity scores.
“Amazon has been on a multi-year campaign to make FBA economically viable only at scale,” said Dalia Patiño, a multichannel commerce consultant who advises mid-market brands on FBA versus FBM strategy. “This would be the next chapter of that story.”
“If your IPI is below 450 and your return rate is above 8%, you should be running scenarios right now on what a 6% to 9% FBA surcharge would do to your unit economics. Don’t wait for the official announcement.” — Dalia Patiño, multichannel commerce consultant
Others are more measured. Robyn Johnson, founder of Marketplace Blueprint, noted in a LinkedIn post last week that Amazon has consistently telegraphed major fee changes through its SAS program before public rollout, and that sellers with strong account health metrics have little to fear. “Panic is not a strategy,” she wrote. “Operational excellence is.”
What Should Sellers Actually Do Right Now?
Given the unconfirmed nature of Project Lighthouse, most operators Ecommerce Times spoke with are taking a “prepare-but-don’t-overreact” posture. The practical advice circulating among experienced FBA operators breaks down into a few clear actions:
- Audit your IPI score and restock cadence — Amazon’s Inventory Performance Index is likely a core input into any velocity metric. Sellers running below 500 should prioritize addressing the root causes, typically excess inventory or restocking gaps.
- Reduce return rate at the listing level — Review your top-returning ASINs and assess whether listing inaccuracies, size charts, or expectation mismatches are driving returns. A 1-point reduction in return rate could materially affect a velocity score.
- Model FBM hybrid scenarios — Several operators are reportedly dusting off FBM fulfillment setups via ShipBob, Deliverr (now Flexport Fulfillment), or in-house 3PLs as a hedge against potential FBA surcharges on underperforming SKUs.
- Get on the phone with your SAS rep — If you have a dedicated Amazon account manager, now is the time to ask direct questions about any upcoming fee structure changes in H2 2026.
- Talk to your agency — Agencies with large managed portfolios may have more informal intelligence from Amazon than individual sellers.
When Might Amazon Officially Announce Project Lighthouse?
Sources close to the matter are pointing to Amazon’s traditional September fee announcement window — historically when the company has previewed the following year’s FBA rate card — as the most likely moment for any official disclosure. If the program is real and the Q4 2026 timeline is accurate, sellers would expect to see something in the next 60 to 90 days.
Until then, Project Lighthouse remains unconfirmed. But in a marketplace where fee changes have already cost mid-size sellers an estimated 3 to 7 margin points since 2023, the chatter alone is enough to send operators back to their spreadsheets. As one seller with $4M in annual FBA revenue put it bluntly: “I stopped waiting for official announcements two years ago. By the time Amazon makes it official, you’ve already lost the quarter.”
Ecommerce Times will continue to monitor developments. If you have direct knowledge of Project Lighthouse or related Amazon internal programs, contact our editorial team securely.